William Turner Pirate 100%

But here’s the question that sent me down a rabbit hole this week:

was a respected English naval captain and later a merchant commander. He is best known for his command of the HMS Oxford and later merchant vessels sailing to the Indies. Turner’s claim to fame wasn’t stealing gold; it was protecting it. He engaged in skirmishes with Barbary corsairs (pirates from North Africa) and defended English trade routes. william turner pirate

For centuries, the painting was mislabeled. So, for a long time, historians thought there was a pirate named William Turner because his portrait was swapped with Kidd’s. When the screenwriters for Pirates of the Caribbean were doing their early research, they likely saw that mislabeled portrait and thought, “What a great name for a hero.” So, the movie version is pure fiction, but it’s fiction built on historical rubble. But here’s the question that sent me down

The short answer is sort of . The long answer involves a fascinating collision of history, a very famous painting, and one of the most successful fictional name-steals in movie history. Let’s get the biggest misconception out of the way first. If you search 17th-century pirate rolls for a Captain William Turner, you won’t find him. There was no infamous buccaneer with that name terrorizing Port Royal. He engaged in skirmishes with Barbary corsairs (pirates